I invite you to visit my Georgia Social Security disability web site to read my latest heart disease disability case study report about a case I tried last week on behalf of a client with a longstanding cardiac disease complicated by decreased kidney function and diabetes. Like many of the cardiac disease cases that I try, there were three viable theories of disability that could apply: (1) a listing argument; (2) a functional capacity argument and (3) a grid rule argument.
Read more on Heart Disease Case Study Posted…
"I am disabled and cannot work." Although this is a very short sentence, it's implications are quite profound. For many of my clients the decision to apply for benefits and assert in writing and verbally that they can no longer earn a living is perhaps the most psychologically difficult part of the disability process.
Read more on Why You Should Hate the Idea of Applying for Disability Beneifts…
As a large federal bureaucracy, the Social Security Administration has a dizzying array of procedures and forms that it uses to process disability cases. Social Security procedure manuals require disability adjudicators and judges to use something called a "sequential evaluation process" to evaluate every disability case. In case you are interested, the five steps of the process are as follows:
Read more on What "Theories of Disability" Work to Win Cases?…
In my law office, I always try to schedule a pre-hearing meeting with my client one to two weeks prior to my client's hearing. I use this meeting to discuss the "big picture" issues and to practice asking and answering questions that my client is likely to face.
One line of questioning that always comes up relates to my client's capacity to perform various physical activities, such as lifting, sitting, standing and walking. Physical activities like these are known as "exertional" activities by the Social Security Administration and one's exertional capacity is almost always a factor in questions asked of the vocational witness.
For Social Security purposes, your exertional capacity is defined as follows:
Sedentary: Requires the ability to sit up to six hours in an eight hour work day, lift light objects such as files and paperwork frequently during the day, and objects weighing up to 10 pounds occasionally during the day.
Light: Requires the ability to stand up to six hours in an eight hour work day, lift up to 10 pounds frequently and up to 20 pounds occasionally.
Medium: Requires the ability to stand up to six hours in an eight hour work day, lift up to 25 pounds frequently and 50 pounds occasionally.
Heavy: Same standing as light and medium, lifting heavier than medium.
As you can see, each of these definitions includes some very specific numbers. When you prepare to testify, you will need to be prepared to discuss your capacities. Read more on Hearing Testimony Tip: Know How Much You Can Lift and How Far You Can Walk…
Social Security disability cases often interface with workers' compensation and short term or long term disability cases. I recently received a question from a lady named Helena, who asks the following:
Read more on Should I File for Social Security if I Also Have a Pending Workers' Comp and LTD Claim…
Many Social Security disability claimants have been diagnosed with diabetes. What does it take to win? Here is a question I received from a reader of this blog:
Jane, my girlfriend of 25 years (54 yrs old) has been diagnosed with Type I Diabetes for 35 years. She has had a number of problems over the years (uncontrollable diarrhea, Retinopathy, Neuropathy) all of which were more or less under control until recently. She has suffered a massive hemorrhage in one of her eyes and is completely blind in one eye. The eye may be able to be helped by surgery but one thing is for certain it will never be as good as it was 3 weeks ago. Jane has been employed as a land surveyor (self employed last 10 yrs) for 30 years and it is very difficult to carry on with the physical impairments brought on by diabetes. Given her age I would very much like to get her on a government sponsored disability program so as to supplement my earnings while waiting for SS retirement to kick in at age 62. Do you think I have any chance of this? Given your experience which of the numerous symptoms of diabetes are the easiest to document for a SSDI claim?
Here are my thoughts: under Social Security's definitions, Jane is "closely approaching advanced age" and has a skilled work background, and quite possibly transferrable skills. Her educational background is not mentioned but I will assume that she has a college education. As such, it is unlikely that any of the medical-vocational guidelines (the grid rules) will apply.
I would therefore analyze her case as Read more on What Factors Does Social Security Consider in a Diabetes Disability Case…
Over the past couple of months, I have taken a number of MS cases to hearings before different judges. So far, we are looking at favorable decisions in all of them. However, the evidence considered by the various judges has been anything but consistent.
Read more on Strategies for Winning Multiple Sclerosis Disability Claims…
Back in 2006, I wrote a blog post entitled "Narcolepsy as a Basis for Social Security Disability." In that post, I noted that there is no "listing" for narcolepsy, meaning that a successful claim would have to rely on a "functional capacity" argument and that you may need more than strictly medical evidence to persuade your judge.
Recently, I received an email from a gentleman named Michael who asked for some additional information:
I have narcolepsy and even the maximum doses of medications don't help. I keep losing jobs and will be losing my current job due to this. I do exceptionally well at my job when I feel alright, but I spend at least twenty hours of the day not functional. I'm currently telecommuting full-time and I still can't stay awake and clear long enough each day to do my work. When I work on-site at a job, people accuse me of being an alcoholic or drug addict because I look terrible and slur my words and fall asleep several times per day. The only thing that prolongs my jobs is that when I'm feeling alright, I am sharper than most and unusually productive. So, they smell my breath and check my arms for tracks and I try to convince them that I'm just tired and that usually suffices for a while, but once again I'm losing my job. I am getting worse as I get older and I can't maintain myself or watch my own child or regularly brush my teeth, etc. It's a horrible situation and I'm looking at losing everything (job loss) and I don't think I will be able to recover my finances this time because my narcolepsy is getting so bad. How could I get disability for this? What happens if a treatment comes around that works, can I get back off disability? If I can somehow start a business and hire other people to do the work in order to get off disability, would I be penalized for trying to get off disability? Even working full-time telecommuting, I get accused of being drunk or using drugs because I randomly sound drunk or on drugs even over the phone. It is so frustrating. Please advise as to what options I have, if any, and thank you for writing something up on the web about this.
Here are my thoughts: Yes, narcolepsy can be the basis for a Social Security disability claim. Please refer to my August, 2006 blog post referenced above. If a new treatment is developed, you may absolutely terminate your disability – in fact, if you return to work you are required to notify the Social Security Administration. Read more on What Strategy Should Narcolepsy Claimant Use to Win Benefits?…
I recently received the following email from a reader of this blog:
I am just wondering if I am wasting my time, my son has been diagnosed adhd for about 4 years now, I think its more but we havent gotten there yet. He is in regular classes but is also in resource at school, he also had to be held back a grade due to his problems the first year being diagnosed. Would he possibly qualify at all for disability benefits.
Jonathan Ginsberg's response: In order to win a child disability case, you will need to show that your child meets a Listing. The Listings for children are different than the Listings for adults. You can review the childhood disability listings by clicking on the link.
Read more on How Do You Evaluate Whether Your Child's SSI Case is Viable?…
A common question that I see has to do with part time work. As I have written previously, I am not a big fan of part time work, as you will see from my answer to this question that I recieved by email:
Read more on Can I File for Disability if I am Working 20 Hours Per Week?…